Butterfinger Pie
Rebecca Blumer
This no-bake peanut butter pie pairs a chilled Oreo crust with a smooth cream cheese filling, airy whipped topping, and crunchy Butterfinger candy pieces.
Prep Time 20 minutes mins
Chilling Time 4 hours hrs
Total Time 4 hours hrs 20 minutes mins
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 12 slices
Calories 341 kcal
Large Mixing Bowl
Electric Mixer
Spatula
- 1 Oreo crust prepared
- 8 ounces cream cheese (1 block)
- ½ cup creamy peanut butter
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 cup powdered sugar
- 12 ounces Butterfingers coarsely chopped
- 1 container Cool Whip (8 ounces) thawed, divided
Follow the preparation directions for your Oreo crust, then refrigerate it while you mix the filling. The chilled shell should feel firm rather than loose and crumbly.
Use a large mixing bowl to beat the cream cheese with the peanut butter, scraping the sides as needed. Stop when the mixture looks uniform and glossy, without tiny white cream cheese specks.
Beat the vanilla and powdered sugar into the peanut butter mixture until evenly incorporated. The filling should look smooth, with no dry sugar pockets along the bowl.
Reserve ⅓ cup of chopped Butterfingers, then gently fold the remaining candy and half the Cool Whip into the filling. Use broad spatula strokes until the candy is distributed and no white ribbons remain.
Fill the chilled crust evenly, cover the filling with the remaining Cool Whip, and finish with the reserved candy. The surface should have an even whipped layer with candy scattered across it.
Let the assembled pie set in the refrigerator for at least 4 hours before cutting. The filling should hold its shape when you lift out a wedge.
Ingredient tip: Use full-fat block cream cheese softened to room temperature and conventional creamy peanut butter so the filling mixes smoothly and holds its shape.
Candy crushing: Tap unwrapped candy bars gently inside a sealed bag with a rolling pin or pulse briefly in a food processor so visible chunks remain instead of dust.
Slicing tip: Chill the pie for at least 4 hours, then dip a sharp knife in warm water and wipe it dry between cuts for clean wedges.
Storage: Refrigerate leftovers covered with a pie carrier or lid that does not touch the whipped topping, and keep any delayed candy garnish in a separate airtight container.
Nutrition information is an estimate based on common ingredients and serving sizes. Values may vary depending on brands, portions, and substitutions.
Keyword butterfinger pie, no-bake butterfinger pie, peanut butter candy bar pie