Add the olive oil or butter, Aleppo pepper, cumin, and smoked paprika to a small skillet and heat over medium for 30 seconds to 1 minute. Look for light bubbling and a fragrant, smoky aroma rather than darkening spices.
Take the skillet off the burner and immediately pour its contents into a heatproof bowl. Removing the mixture from the hot skillet keeps residual heat from scorching the pepper.
Mix the yogurt, grated garlic, and salt in a medium bowl. The garlic and seasoning should be evenly distributed through the thick yogurt.
Crack each egg into its own small bowl or ramekin, then bring water in a medium pot to a gentle boil. The water should move gently rather than churn vigorously.
Add the vinegar, stir the water into a circular current, gently release the eggs into it, and give the water another gentle stir. Cook for 3½ to 4 minutes, checking for set whites and yolks cooked to your preference.
Lift the eggs with a slotted spoon and place them on a plate to drain slightly. Let excess poaching water run away so it doesn’t thin the yogurt.
Spread the yogurt thickly across two plates or bowls, add two eggs to each, and finish with the spiced oil or butter, salt and black pepper to taste, and dill or parsley. Serve with pita so each bite can gather the creamy yogurt, warm egg, and fragrant drizzle.