Bring the syrup water, sugar, cinnamon sticks, whole cloves, and halved orange to a boil in a pot, cook for 3–4 minutes, then take the pot off the heat and stir in the syrup honey. The sugar should have dissolved before the honey goes in; leave the finished syrup to cool completely.
Whisk the fine semolina, soft flour, and baking powder together in a bowl. The mixture should look uniform, without concentrated patches of baking powder.
Combine the orange juice, cognac, sugar, powdered cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and vanilla in a separate large bowl, then add the baking soda and whisk immediately for 5–10 seconds. Visible foam signals that the soda is reacting with the juice as it dissolves.
Whisk the dough water, olive oil, vegetable or sunflower oil, orange zest, and dough honey into the foamy mixture. The liquids should come together with the zest distributed throughout.
Work the dry mixture into the wet mixture gently with your hands, stopping as soon as the dough comes together. A soft, smooth dough with a slightly tacky surface is the goal, rather than a firm dough that needs more kneading.
Line 4 large baking trays with parchment, shape walnut-sized portions of about 30g / 1oz into smooth ovals, and lightly press each top with a fork before piercing it three times about halfway through. Keep the portions similar in size, with visible fork marks across their tops.
Bake the first two prepared trays if your oven accommodates them, allowing approximately 15–20 minutes and longer for larger cookies. Look for light, even browning and cookies that have cooked through.
Immerse the freshly baked cookies immediately in the cold syrup for approximately 10–20 seconds, turning them with a slotted spoon, then lift them onto a platter and scatter chopped walnuts over them. Choose the shorter or longer end of the dipping range according to how syrupy you want the cookies.
Put the remaining two trays into the oven while dipping the first batch, and set a timer for the next bake. Check the next batch for the same light, even browning before repeating the syrup dip.